Oggi sull'Arena è stato pubblicato questo articolo: " Discarica di Caluri, no alla riapertura " che ha questi sottotitoli: " Il Consiglio di Stato ha respinto la richiesta della società Rope di revisione della sentenza del Tar dell'anno scorso. I magistrati ribadiscono la decisione che annullò l'autorizzazione allo stoccaggio dei rifiuti «Ridotta possibilità di contaminazione della falda»" e che ha questo testo:
Il Consiglio di Stato ha detto no alla riapertura della discarica di Caluri. I giudici hanno respinto la richiesta, avanzata dalla società Rope, di revisione della sentenza del 2010, con cui il Tribunale amministrativo regionale di Venezia (Tar) annulled the authorization regional storage of putrescible waste in the village.
Judges of the Fifth Chamber reiterated the terms of the Tar over a year ago in the procedure for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is required for the license, was not involved with the City of Povegliano, although its territory near the the landfill.
President Pier Giorgio Trovato, and other magistrates, the ruling showed "the potential risk of injury to justify the award to the City of Povegliano, the status of the entities concerned impacts from the landfill." They stressed that the country could be reached from any propagation of pollutants, because there are two wells on its territory of the aqueduct, downstream from the site of the Rope. The judges noted "that there has been reduced, and therefore clearly not ruled out the possibility of groundwater contamination by leachate. Prosecutors have concluded that the lack of involvement of Povegliano prevented at the same institution "to make the necessary proposals to deal with the installation of a waste landfill, in an area considered sensitive." The lawyer Julian
dolphins, defender, along with lawyer Nicola Avanzi, the interests of the municipality of Villafranca in the proceedings against Rope, explained: "With my colleague I note with satisfaction of the rejection of the appeal, and of accepting full of our demands. " He then remarked: "The verdict has finally pointed out the illegality of the proceedings Street, and adopted the more occasions on the extreme fragility of the site." Dolphins continued: "Rope must now consider whether to retrace the process from the very first step of the way, based on principles of far greater attention than hitherto."
more prudent assessment of the mayor villafranchese Mario Faccioli. "The State Council has recognized a procedural issue," he said, "and are now waiting to see how to involve the company." Annamaria Bigon, Mayor of Povegliano, heaved a sigh of relief. "We had instructed the lawyer Alessandra Rigobello," he pointed out, "and we were made to the left of Villafranca, never having been summoned for the EIA procedure. The rest of our opposition to the site had been highlighted in recent years, with a resolution of the City Council. "
An applause came from the Civic Committee for heat and Legambiente. Anna Maria Bertolini, president of the Committee, said: "After 26 years of hard work and money spent, we got right. We will remain vigilant. Now we want that in the new land use plan (Pat), the area of \u200b\u200bthe landfill is included among the environmental protection. " "The ruling is good, 'she said Michele Bertucco, presidente regionale di Legambiente, «e la ditta, se vorrà riottenere l'autorizzazione, dovrà ripartire con dei paletti in più. Con la legge finanziaria 2010 saranno indispensabili alcuni passaggi aggiuntivi, a cominciare da una delibera favorevole del Consiglio provinciale, previo parere dell'osservatorio rifiuti dell'Agenzia regionale per la protezione dell'ambiente del Veneto (Arpav), che accerti l'indispensabilità dell'impianto stesso».
Un articolo simile a questo è uscito anche sul Corriere di Verona (inserto del Corriere della Sera) che qui sotto si riproduce:
.
Il Consiglio di Stato ha detto no alla riapertura della discarica di Caluri. I giudici hanno respinto la richiesta, avanzata dalla società Rope, di revisione della sentenza del 2010, con cui il Tribunale amministrativo regionale di Venezia (Tar) annulled the authorization regional storage of putrescible waste in the village.
Judges of the Fifth Chamber reiterated the terms of the Tar over a year ago in the procedure for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is required for the license, was not involved with the City of Povegliano, although its territory near the the landfill.
President Pier Giorgio Trovato, and other magistrates, the ruling showed "the potential risk of injury to justify the award to the City of Povegliano, the status of the entities concerned impacts from the landfill." They stressed that the country could be reached from any propagation of pollutants, because there are two wells on its territory of the aqueduct, downstream from the site of the Rope. The judges noted "that there has been reduced, and therefore clearly not ruled out the possibility of groundwater contamination by leachate. Prosecutors have concluded that the lack of involvement of Povegliano prevented at the same institution "to make the necessary proposals to deal with the installation of a waste landfill, in an area considered sensitive." The lawyer Julian
dolphins, defender, along with lawyer Nicola Avanzi, the interests of the municipality of Villafranca in the proceedings against Rope, explained: "With my colleague I note with satisfaction of the rejection of the appeal, and of accepting full of our demands. " He then remarked: "The verdict has finally pointed out the illegality of the proceedings Street, and adopted the more occasions on the extreme fragility of the site." Dolphins continued: "Rope must now consider whether to retrace the process from the very first step of the way, based on principles of far greater attention than hitherto."
more prudent assessment of the mayor villafranchese Mario Faccioli. "The State Council has recognized a procedural issue," he said, "and are now waiting to see how to involve the company." Annamaria Bigon, Mayor of Povegliano, heaved a sigh of relief. "We had instructed the lawyer Alessandra Rigobello," he pointed out, "and we were made to the left of Villafranca, never having been summoned for the EIA procedure. The rest of our opposition to the site had been highlighted in recent years, with a resolution of the City Council. "
An applause came from the Civic Committee for heat and Legambiente. Anna Maria Bertolini, president of the Committee, said: "After 26 years of hard work and money spent, we got right. We will remain vigilant. Now we want that in the new land use plan (Pat), the area of \u200b\u200bthe landfill is included among the environmental protection. " "The ruling is good, 'she said Michele Bertucco, presidente regionale di Legambiente, «e la ditta, se vorrà riottenere l'autorizzazione, dovrà ripartire con dei paletti in più. Con la legge finanziaria 2010 saranno indispensabili alcuni passaggi aggiuntivi, a cominciare da una delibera favorevole del Consiglio provinciale, previo parere dell'osservatorio rifiuti dell'Agenzia regionale per la protezione dell'ambiente del Veneto (Arpav), che accerti l'indispensabilità dell'impianto stesso».
Un articolo simile a questo è uscito anche sul Corriere di Verona (inserto del Corriere della Sera) che qui sotto si riproduce:
.
.
Ovviamente dopo aver letto questi articoli, I logged on to the website of the State Council to seek Cited in the two articles, and after a short search, I downloaded the Judgement No. 3430/2010 of 8 March 2011 . And this
LANDFILL (as others) I had already written on February 14, 2010, in this message: "The EIA dump: the" heat "and" Ve-Part "and" Ca di Capri " and (of course) of "Siberia" are all the "VIA ILLEGAL"? (to be redone?) "message which I attached the image below:
.
. Viewed
Judgement of the TAR of Veneto No. 304-2010 e visto quanto è stato anche confermato nella Sentenza del Consiglio di Stato, credo sia utile ricordare qualcosa di queste sentenze, in particolare quest'ultima di cui estraggo questi brani:
.
2.Con la sentenza appellata i Primi Giudici hanno accolto il ricorso proposto dal Comune di Villafranca di Verona reputando fondata la censura con la quale era stato dedotto il vizio di omessa partecipazione al procedimento del Comune di Povegliano Veronese .
.
Va in ogni caso soggiunto che nella specie la parte originariamente ricorrente non aveva dedotto il mero profilo dell’omessa comunicazione di avvio del procedimento ma il più significativo profilo della violazione della prescrizione di cui all’art. 2 of Law No 10/1999, which gives the municipalities concerned to formulate the opinion referred al'comma 2 of Article 5 of Decree 12 April 1996 and art. 17 of Law No 10/1999 and the rules (see in particular Articles. 19 bis and 23 of the same regional legislation) covering integration of EIA with the composition of the Commission ' inclusion of representatives of the municipalities involved .
.
Article. 2, the letter m, called a community those interested in whose territory the facility is located, work or action, and any other municipalities concerned and the environmental impacts, as identified in the SIA under Articles 9 and 13, to which it express the opinion referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 5 of Decree 12 April 1996. Article. 9, in turn, provides for what is relevant, the SIA and interdisciplinary must contain at least information relating to the identification of the municipalities and provinces involved referred to m) and n) of paragraph 1 Article 2. Article. 13 Finally, states that, within sixty days of receipt of the application of Articles 10, 11 or 12, the structure responsible for the EIA shall provide for the formal documentation submitted, expressing, inter alia, in order to identify municipalities, provinces and possibly the management bodies of protected areas concerned, for the expression of the opinion referred to in paragraph 2 of Article 5 DPR 12 April 1996;
.
The judge of first instance has correctly pointed out that the opinion of the EIA Regional Commission, which was approved by the contested measure, identifies (page 24 of Annex A to DGR n ° 1115 of April 28, 2009) as an area potentially affected by the propagation of pollutants in the subsurface bounded by a radius of 2 km upstream from the landfill the direction of groundwater flow and by a radius of 5 km downstream of the site.
.
It ultimately became clear that the lack of recognition, on the part of the City of Povegliano Veronese status has prevented the municipality concerned to provide the same inputs regional qualified under the laws in order to assess the adequacy of the measures listed and submit proposals to this end necessary to address the potential prejudice resulting from the installation of a landfill in an area considered sensitive, like the parameters set by DGR n ° 1115 of April 28, 2009, for two points of collection which draws from the local authority concerned to achieve the necessary water resources.
6. The foregoing considerations require the rejection of appeals - However, there are good reasons to bear its own costs. - PQM - The Council of State in the courts (Section Five) saying definitively on appeals, as in the epigraph proposed rejects them.
.
And now rephrase the question: If the Commission
former VIA Regional Cava Siberia, did not participate in the town of Villafranca "as the common interest", which is located within 5 km downstream of the former Quarry Siberia (see above image ) that opinion is illegal, how then is invalidate the Regional Resolution which approved the Environmental Recovery of the former Quarry FAKE Siberia (but REAL landfill waste)?
And tomorrow I add another:
the light of the Judgement of the State Council, now what will Sommapop.orgini who wanted their discarichetta ... par to the Schei? Tomorrow
a letter to the Mayor and copied to the Prosecutor's Office concerning "the fake Environmental Recovery and Landfill VERA former Cava Siberia " e. .. then we put a lid on it.
Obviously if someone has made a mistake ... ri_ovviamente must pay for the damage ... ri_ri_ovviamente also assume all the responsibilities (administrative fines and penalties). Place
